Board Thread:News and Announcements/@comment-25793989-20190201214139/@comment-34979284-20190202152024

Yikes - this is a hard one! I'm sorry Blue, but I'll have to go with the Giving.

The Giving really kept me reading. The plot is interesting, it has a good introduction about the characters. Everything in the story is written in detail, which definately adds that extra bit of creepiness to the story. Although The Gift of Happiness also has an interesting plot, it started off slow, and the dialogue was confusing - Who was talking to who? And why add so many dots?

The Giving also had more sudden plot twists. It's also more "Minecrafty" feel than the other one. (Not like it matters) However I don't think that really affects which story is better.

I mean, I found both stories interesting, and definately creepy to say the least. However I found Shraut's story more professionaly written than Blue's.

The Giving: 5 - 6 votes, The Gift: 5 votes.